MeanGene Rants                                                                    17 November 2002

The Solar Chimney –

Sunlight, lots of glass, a giant tower and electricity.

Readers Rant Back

Fuel Cells, Fuel Cells, Fuels Cells

 

Cool Stuff

 

·        Laptop Fuel Cell approved for Airplanes http://www.fuelcelltoday.com/FuelCellToday/IndustryInformation/IndustryInformationExternal/NewsDisplayArticle/0,1471,1888,00.html

·        Are Nuclear Powered Laptops Next? http://news.com.com/2100-1001-965640.html?tag=fd_top

·        Wisconsinites (aka Cheesheads) Make Electricity From Duck Shit http://www.wildlifehc.org/news/othernews/Index.cfm?Page=1&NewsID=22613

 

Readers Rant back on Fuel Cell Cars

Several people responded to the idea of a fuel cell car with something like "remember the Hindenberg" the famous German Hydrogen-filled blimp that went up in flames. Well, it turns out that the flames had more to do with the paint on the shell of the blimp than the hydrogen inside. A helium-filled Hindenberg would have burned just as much. http://www.dwv-info.de/pm/hindbg/hbe.htm Others even claim that Hydrogen is safer than gasoline or diesel. A car leaking 3000 cubic feet per minute of hydrogen when set on fire generates less heat inside the car than sunshine. http://www.rmi.org/sitepages/pid536.php

Others wondered how fuel cell cars can take off before fuel-cell gas stations sprout up, and why the stations would sprout up if there are no fuel cell cars - a real catch-22. David Garman, assistant US secretary for energy efficiency, said 30 to 40 percent of US gas stations ... would have to offer hydrogen to make fuel cell vehicles viable. Most likely fuel cell cars would start with fleet vehicles, the US Postal service has 400 battery powered fleet vehicles already in CA and serves as a good model. http://www.wildlifehc.org/news/othernews/Index.cfm?Page=1&NewsID=22456 Daimler-Chrysler will start testing fuel cell powered fleet vehicles in 2003. http://biz.yahoo.com/prnews/021008/detu012_1.html

Experts at the Rocky Mountain Institute and elsewhere predict that buildings may become widespread users of fuel cells before cars. General Motors is betting that this view is correct and will start offering stationary fuel cell power systems to mission critical buildings like hospitals, cell phone networks and data processing centers in 2004. http://www.buildings.com/Articles/detail.asp?ArticleID=965

Whether it is fleet vehicles, buildings or both, as more and more fuel cells need to be resupplied, local distribution centers of hydrogen will become more common.

Solar Chimney

The solar chimney is a simple idea that is not very well known. The basic description is here http://www.stirlingengines.org.uk/sun/sola6.html  Or a picture can speak a thousand words about it. http://www.meangene.com/energy/solarChimney.html  A quick time movie doesn't add a lot more, but it's cool. http://www.enviromission.com.au/index1.htm

The basic idea is that the sun heats up the air underneath a huge spread of glass around the base of the chimney. The hot air rises and has only one path to do that, through the chimney. The chimney is lined with turbines that generate electricity. The speed of the air inside is proportional to the temperature difference from bottom to top. Therefore, the taller the chimney and the wider its collection base, the more energy it can produce.

The idea comes from Germany, but Germany doesn't have a lot of hot desert-like areas to try it out, so they built a small 30MW prototype in Manzanares, Spain - .

Sri Lanka also has a prototype, and wants to build a real 200MW system. http://www.gluckman.com/SolarChimney.html But Australia wants to be the first and may beat them out. http://www.abc.net.au/7.30/s359035.htm If they go through with their plan, they will build the world's tallest structure, twice as tall as the Petronas Twin Towers in Kuala Lumpur.

"The 1000m Solar Chimney in Mildura, Australia, will be the highest man-made structure on Earth, and can produce 200MW of electricity, providing power to 200,000 homes. The cost to build the tower is estimated at AUS$700 million (US$395 million), about 14 percent more than an equivalent coal-fired power station, and about 70 percent more per installed megawatt than a comparable wind farm. However, the investment will pay off in long term because it is more reliable than wind farm in sun-rich Australia and requires no fuel. By building the solar chimney power plant, the Australian government target of producing 2% of energy from renewable sources by 2010 (9500 GigaWatt hours) could be met easily." http://www.visionengineer.com/env/solar_flue2.shtml

The energy is free, but 97% of the energy is still lost using the original German design. This design tries to improve on the original. http://www.globalwarmingsolutions.co.uk/the_solar_chimney.htm

Eric Hu, a senior lecturer in energy and thermal engineering at Melbourne's Deakin University, suggests any greenhouse benefits could be a fantasy. "That's because by trapping heat, such a chimney could reduce Earth's 'albedo,' or ability to reflect light back into space. Thus, by transforming solar radiation into heat, a solar chimney might actually contribute to warming earth's atmosphere even while reducing emissions of greenhouse gases.